Ratings

Since everyone else seems to be clarifying, and since I get the idea mine are probably a touch...odd compared to many people, I thought I would go ahead and jump on the "explain your ratings" bandwagon, here. I think you can find this way, way back in my blog somewhere, and in addition I have it linked on the main page of my blog here: Ratings

but there's no reason not to double up on it, I figure. So here we go: 

 

I generally use Goodreads' five star system. I love it.

 

1 Star: Didn't like it.

 

2 Stars: Thought it was okay.

 

3 Stars: Liked it.

 

4 Stars: Really liked it.

 

5 Stars: Loved it.

 

I like the simplicity of it and the fact that it is clearly tied to my feelings on the book. I have always hated trying to assign star ratings to things when they are book-based. Is something a good book or a great book? I have absolutely no idea, honestly. I am not sure I am qualified to judge that or what the specifications are for it. I have certainly disagreed with things popularly considered to be "great works" before, and I am sure I will again.

 

I do know if liked or didn't like a book, though. This is sometimes due to things that make books good versus great, but honestly, not always. If you lined up all my five star books in a row and said that they were all equally "great" books in a strictly objective sense, even I would laugh.

 

Although I know many deeply appreciate the half-star ratings here on Booklikes, I have yet to use them and I don't really see myself doing it. It clutters things in my head and makes it much harder for me to evaluate books. I am comfortable with the dividing line I have between "liked it" and "really liked it." I am not sure where to place a line for "liked it and a half but didn't really like it." I liked some of my three-star-rated books more than some of the others, but I am confident in declaring that I liked all of them more than my two-star-rated and less than my four-star-rated.

 

My average rating over on Goodreads for everything I have read is 3.06, and I figure that is pretty good. Three is my default rating for anything I read and didn't have any serious complaints about. I liked it. And I feel like I "like" most of what I read. I am not seriously annoyed, but I am rarely delirious with joy, either. My five star ratings are handed out quite sparingly and I do go back later and re-evaluate those in particular.